CBC Marketplace had researchers watch what six of the most popular apps in Canada send out of a phone: Tim Hortons, PC Optimum, the Weather Network, Facebook, Amazon and YouTube. Every one of them discloses in its terms that it collects and shares data, and every company says it does not sell personal information. The scans show how much leaves the phone anyway, and how far it travels.
Here is what that looks like over one ordinary morning, drawn from what the researchers saw:
You open the Tim Hortons app for a coffee. Before you tap anything, the app appeared to send an overseas third party enough to fingerprint your phone and recognize it later: the name you gave the device, an identifier unique to it, a list of its sensors, the details of its camera, the names of your ringtones and alarms, and the names of the Wi-Fi routers around you, which can be used to work out where you are. Tim Hortons says that company uses it for fraud and payment abuse prevention, not advertising, and is not allowed to sell it.
You check the Weather Network on the way out. With location switched on, a third party appeared to receive your precise latitude and longitude, your local conditions and your advertising ID. That ID does not change, so every check adds another point to a location history. Pelmorex says the app uses location only with permission, to give you local weather and relevant ads, and sells nothing.
You search PC Optimum for prenatal vitamins. Ten outside companies appeared to be told what you searched for. One received your coordinates and a unique device identifier. Another, overseas, received your first name, your email address unredacted, your member number and a record of how you use the app. Loblaw says it has never sold personal information.
You post one photo to Facebook. Having been given the camera roll, the app appeared to collect metadata about photos and videos you did not upload, their file names, dates, times and camera settings, along with the coordinates of the one picture you did post. It also logged every scroll and how long you lingered. Meta did not comment on the findings; its policy says it collects this and sells nothing.
Amazon and YouTube came out of it better. Neither appeared to hand anything to outside companies during the test, though Amazon logged what was searched for along with the advertising ID, and YouTube showed no targeted advertising against a children’s video. Joel Reardon, the University of Calgary computer scientist who ran the Android scans, called what he found “a monstrous data collection surveillance system”. Ann Cavoukian, Ontario’s former privacy commissioner, said people have no real control over where any of it ends up.
None of this was a break-in. It is the trade people accept when they tap Agree. The researchers say there is little you can do to stop the transmission once an app is installed, so their advice is to delete the apps you are not using and keep only the ones you need. The app-by-app findings are in CBC’s companion report.

https://www.cbc.ca/news/marketplace/the-app-trap-9.7419266
Where the image above is taken from the linked article, it remains the property of the publication, photographer or rights holder who created it and is not owned or licensed by Truespeed. It is shown to identify the story, which you can read in full at the source. Rights holders can write to legal@truespeed.ca.



